|  | |
| 1951 | |  Kiki Haakonson (Sweden) |
| 1952 |   |  May-Louise Flodin (Sweden) |
| 1953 |   |  Denise Perrier (France) |
| 1954 |   |  Antigone Costanda (Egypt) |
| 1955 |   |  Carmen Susana Duijim Zubillaga (Venezuela) |
| 1956 |   |  Petra Schurmann (Germany) |
| 1957 |   |  Marita Lindahl (Finland) |
| 1958 |   |  Penelope Anne Coelen (South Africa) |
| 1959 |   |  Corine Rottschafer (Netherlands) |
| 1960 |   |  Norma Gladys Cappagli (Argentina) |
| 1961 |   |  Rosemarie Frankland (United Kingdom) |
| 1962 |   |  Catharina Lodders (Holland) |
| 1963 |   |  Carole Joan Crawford (Jamaica) |
| 1964 |   |  Ann Sydney (United Kingdom) |
| 1965 |   |  Lesley Langley (United Kingdom) |
| 1966 |   |  Reita Faria (India) |
| 1967 |   |  Madeleine Hartog Bell (Peru) |
| 1968 |   |  Penelope Plummer (Australia) |
| 1969 |   |  Eva Von Rueber Staier (Austria) |
| 1970 |   |  Jennifer Josephine Hoste (Grenada) |
| 1971 |   |  Lucia Petterle (Brazil) |
| 1972 |   |  Belinda Green (Australia) |
| 1973 |   |  Marjorie Wallace (United States) |
| 1974 |   |  Anneline Kriel (South Africa) |
| 1975 |   |  Wilnelia Merced (Puerto Rico) |
| 1976 |   |  Cindy Breakspeare (Jamaica) |
| 1977 |   |  Mary Ann Catrim Stavin (Sweden) |
| 1978 |   |  Silvana Suarez (Argentina) |
| 1979 |   |  Gina Swainson (Bermuda) |
| 1980 |   |  Kimberly Santos (Guam) |
| 1981 |   |  Pilin Leon (Venezuela) |
| 1982 |   |  Mariasela Alvarez Lebron (Dominican Republic) |
| 1983 |   |  Sarah-Jane Hutt (United Kingdom) |
| 1984 |   |  Astrid Carolina Herrera Irazabal (Venezuela) |
| 1985 |   |  Hofi Karlsdottir (Iceland) |
| 1986 |   |  Giselle Jeanne-Marie Laronde (Trinidad & Tobago) |
| 1987 |   |  Ulla Weigerstorfer (Austria) |
| 1988 |   |  Linda Petursdottier (Iceland) |
| 1989 |   |  Aneta Kreglicka (Poland) |
| 1990 |   |  Gina Marie Tolleson (United States) |
| 1991 |   |  Ninibeth Leal (Venezuela) |
| 1992 |   |  Julia Kourotchkina (Russia) |
| 1993 |   |  Lisa Hanna (Jamaica) |
| 1994 |   |  Aishwarya Rai (India) |
| 1995 |   |  Jacqueline Aguilera Marcano (Venezuela) |
| 1996 |   |  Irene Skilva (Greece) |
| 1997 |   |  Diana Hayden (India) |
| 1998 |   |  Linor Abargil (Israel) |
| 1999 |   |  Yukta Mookhey (India) |
| 2000 |   |  Priyanka Chopra (India) |
| 2001 |   |  Agbani Darego (Nigeria) |
| 2002 |   |  Azra Akin (Turkey) |
| 2003 |   |  Rosanna Davison (Ireland) |
| 2004 |   |  Maria Julia Mantilla Garcia (Peru) |
| 2005 |  Natalie Glebova (Canada) |  Unnur Birna VILHJALMSDOTTIR(Iceland) |
| 2006 |  Zuleyka Rivera |  Tatána Kucharová(Czech Republic) |
| 2007 |  Riyo Mori |  Zhang Zilin(China) |
| 2008 |  Dayana Mendoza |  Ksenia Sukhinova(Russia) |
| 2009 |  Stefania Fernandez (Venezuela
) |  Kaiane Aldorino(Gibraltar) |